Welcome to Cedar Grill & Pizza, a cherished gem nestled in Caldwell, NJ. Located conveniently at 295 Bloomfield Ave Ste 2, this pizza restaurant has become a local favorite, known for both its delectable offerings and the warm, inviting atmosphere that greets every guest.
Cedar Grill & Pizza boasts a diverse menu that caters to all tastes. Their famous fat sandwiches, often highlighted by customers, are a must-try. These exceptional sandwiches, perfectly proportioned, evoke nostalgia for the lively food truck scene, delivering both flavor and comfort in every bite. Beyond the sandwiches, their classic pizzas are celebrated for their freshness and quality. Many patrons rave that enjoying a slice straight out of the oven is an experience like no other.
For those craving something different, Cedar Grill & Pizza offers a selection of cold sandwiches, such as the Falafel Sandwich and the Tuna Fish Submarine, perfect for a quick bite or a leisurely lunch. And, if pasta is on your mind, their Build Your Own Pasta option allows diners to customize their meal, featuring choices like Italian Sausage Parmigiana and Chicken Parmigiana.
No meal is complete without dessert, and Cedar Grill & Pizza has an array of tempting treats. The homemade rice pudding is particularly noteworthy, offering a creamy, comforting finish to your dining experience. Other delightful options include the rich Tiramisu and classic Carrot Cake.
Beyond the exceptional food, patrons often comment on the stellar service provided by the friendly staff. From the moment you walk in, you are met with a welcoming smile and a feeling of community. This laid-back vibe makes Cedar Grill & Pizza not just a place to grab a meal but a spot to unwind with friends and family.
In a world where food often takes precedence over the experience, Cedar Grill & Pizza strikes a perfect balance. With fresh ingredients, a superb selection, and a welcoming atmosphere, it’s no wonder that this restaurant has garnered such a loyal following. I highly recommend making Cedar Grill & Pizza your next dining destination; you’ll leave feeling satisfied and eager to return.
For more information, call them at +1 973-403-7787. Trust me, you won’t regret it!
Your opinion matters! Help other visitors discover this spot. Your email will stay private. Fields with * are required.
Woodfold Ln, Preston PR3 1AW, United Kingdom
26730 56 Ave #201, Langley Twp, BC V4W 3X5, Canada
301 N Main St, Seneca, IL 61360, United States
Blvd. Juan Ley Fong, Alturas del Sur, Mercado de Abastos, 80295 Culiacán Rosales, Sin., Mexico
Nicaluz Raagas
02/10/2025
Ordered a fat sandwich here, was my first time. If you’re in the area stop by this establishment is extremely polite and professional. Oh and the food? Exceptional.
Luciano R
16/09/2025
I've been coming to Cedar Grill and Pizza for lunch regularly, and it's become one of my go-to spots for good reason. Whether I'm grabbing a cheesesteak, chicken sandwich, salad, pizza, or their amazing broccoli cheese bites, the food is always fresh and packed with flavor. I really love their cheesesteak and they've actually become a ritual at my job—we all chip in and have "Cheesesteak Fridays" every week! It's that level of quality that keeps us coming back for more. What really makes this place special, though, is the service. The crew here is incredibly friendly and always happy to help, making you feel right at home every time you walk in. The atmosphere is laid-back with that classic hometown pizza shop vibe, which is a nice break during the day. For tasty food, great staff, and reasonable prices, Cedar Grill and Pizza is a place I highly recommend!
Xuan Vu
07/09/2025
One of the best places to have a "fresh" pizza experience. i have not been back here for a long time, but the pizza is still as amazing as the first time. It is hard to find consistent food quality. Like many foods, you have to eat out of the oven. Take out is something else.
Christopher Domowicz
01/09/2025
Stopped in for lunch with some friends and each of us ordered different versions of their "fat sandwiches." The category may be a bit off-putting to some, but I must say the way they perfectly proportioned the sandwiches was amazing! They were just the right size with proper ratios of the ingredients to make these sandwiches taste incredible. It also brought us back to the days of visiting our friends at Rutgers University and the food trucks that would be out late at night serving these delicious sandwiches! Not to mention that the owners were super friendly, warm and inviting! We will definitely be back and highly recommend!
Connor Vallee
19/07/2025
When I say I EXCLUSIVELY order from Cedar Grill, I mean it. Excellent pizza. Awesome people. Great service. They have it all (including fat sandwiches).
Adelin Figueroa
17/07/2025
Wasn’t sure which Fat Sandwich to get and the gentleman at the cashier/chef was super cool and nice! He recommended the Fat Don Sandwich. Now, I’ve had a fat sandwich in another restaurant and the quality was horrible. BUT this place! The ingredients are fresh! And the Fat Don Sandwich was DELICIOUS! The combo in the sandwich just works so well together. Def try a Fat Sandwich from here.
Srikar Kodati
10/07/2025
Moved to town a few weeks ago. All other pizzerias were very expensive and not welcoming. Cedar Grills new owners are extremely kind and have reasonable and affordable pricing. The buffalo chicken is my absolute favorite and best I ever had. 10/10 do recommend them. They have great variety of fat sandwiches and appetizers too!!